The Great Terror In The Ukraine History Essay

The Great Panic 1937 – 1938 engulfed the whole Soviet Union and aimed at the devastation of existent and imagined enemies of Stalin, animating in all sections of the population a sense of fright and insecurity, dependance and entry to the “ great leader ” . The decease punishment took platitude and was non a topic to appeal. At best, the “ public enemy ” spent a long term of imprisonment in Siberian labour cantonments.

Although Stalin considered repressions as an subsidiary component of communism edifice, they turned to be the lone tool in accomplishing inexplicit obeisance. As Danilenko points, repression was an built-in portion of the totalitarian system operation, the system which “ required changeless being of fright, lasting resistance to person and something – whether external, or internal enemy. ”[ 1 ]

The most aggregate “ cleansing ” of “ public enemies ” in the full Soviet epoch, which was theoretically grounded by Commissar of the Soviet NKVD Nikolai Ezhov and was personally approved by Stalin, began harmonizing to the order a„- 00447 in August 5, 1937. It was supposed to last four months. In fact, it took over 15 months and was terminated by declaration of the Politburo on November 15, 1938 holding the programs for “ enemies ” increased in several times. The destiny of the Ukraine is peculiarly interesting in respects the Great Terror.

In this paper I will discourse the execution of the panic in the Ukraine during 1937-1938, briefly touching the pre Great Terror state of affairs in the state. Traveling on, I am willing to depict the history of the killing field of Bykivnya, used as a burial topographic point for the victims of the province policy, and to analyse every bit good as to oppugn the figure of victims of the Great Terror buried at that place, and the veracity of the studies refering the diggings, establishing on the analysis of the stuffs from declassified archives of the Ukrainian NKVD.

The prostration of the Soviet Union exposed many classified stuffs of the Ukrainian NKVD, which helped to gauge the figure of victims every bit good as to place the topographic points of mass entombments. However, there are non many scientific beginnings refering the Great Terror in the Ukraine available in English. This may be an obstruction for many non Ukrainian research workers to research the afore-mentioned period in the history of the Ukraine. Nevertheless, many Ukrainian historiographers explore the Stalinist panic in the Ukraine. Among them are Nikolskyi, Shapoval and Bilokin, who made a significant part to the survey of this issue. Some of their plants were used in composing this paper.

2. The Prerequisites of the Great Terror in the Ukraine.

2.1. The Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic

The Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic was the 2nd largest Soviet democracy, bordered with Poland and Romania.[ 2 ]As stated by the Soviet nose count of 1926 the Ukrainian population comprised 21 % of the entire Soviet and 45 % of the non-Russian people. It reached about 30 million people, being the most dumbly populated democracy within the non-Russian parts of the USSR.[ 3 ]Furthermore, Ukrainian provincials made up a half of all non-Russian provincials in the Soviet Union[ 4 ]and constituted five sixth of the whole Ukrainian population. Appendix 1 nowadayss the map of the rural population distribution in the Ukrainian SSR in 1926. This ocular information helps to measure the societal construction of the Ukraine where urban population comprised around five million people.

The Ukraine considered holding powerful economic potency[ 5 ]and an of import geopolitical location. The state of affairs of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic as the last socialist state on the boundary line with capitalist enemies gave the hope to the Soviet leading to change over these provinces to communism. The Ukraine produced “ more than 20 % of the industrial end product ”[ 6 ], and holding fertile dirts, one-quarter of the entire grain production in the Soviet Union.

2.2. Repressions before the Great Panic

Before the beginning of the Great Terror in 1937, Ukrainians experienced several moving ridges of repressions. It can be explained by the programs of the Soviet leading to closely bind together the Ukrayina with the centre.[ 7 ]Thereby, in the period of 1929-1932 several repressions against intellectuals, spiritual curates and applied scientists were conducted, among them: “ Shakhty ” instance ( 1929 ) , “ Union for the Liberation of Ukraine ” instance ( 1930 ) , settlement of Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church ( 1931 ) and “ Ukrainian national Centre ‘ instance ( 1931 ) .[ 8 ]

During 1932-1934 the NKVD was chiefly concerned with “ dekulakization ” , exile of provincials, and fiction of instances against “ counter-revolutionary organisations ” . Around 199 312 people were arrested by security variety meats in 1932-1933.[ 9 ]Surely the biggest calamity for Ukrainians during that clip was the creative activity of unreal dearth ( “ Holodomor ” 1932-1933 ) , which should be addressed as both “ class- and nationally-oriented [ repressions ] ”[ 10 ].

It is of import to advert repressions against cultural minorities of Poles and Germans who were chiefly deported from the district of the Ukraine. Vasiliev stressed that:

“ In March 1935 about 3,500 families were deported from the Kyiv and Vinnitsa oblasti. In January 1936, 1A 500 families were removed from Vinitsa oblast. At the terminal of 1936, a farther 4A 048 families were sent to Kazakhstan. ”[ 11 ]

During the old ages of Holodomor and dekulakization the Ukrainian population decreased harmonizing to different histories on two to four and a half million of people. Consequently, the state approached the twelvemonth of the Great Terror already rather “ filtered ” by the NKVD.

3. The Great Panic in the Ukrayina

3.1. Limits

The Great Terror in the Ukraine was initiated by the NKVD order No 00447 of 30 July 1937 likewise in the USSR in general. It followed a Politburo determination refering “ anti-Soviet elements ” from 2 July 1937, giving the direction to all local governments and NKVD subdivisions to roll up and show the lists of “ kulaks, felons and other anti-Soviet elements ”[ 12 ]to be repressed. The objects of repressions had two ways: either to be changeable or to be sent to the GULAG.

After a spot more than a month, in August 1937, the bounds for the Ukraine were “ calculated ” and amounted 28A 800 victims. The Numberss were estimated in the field and so sent to the Ukrainian NKVD section a„-8, which presented quota to the USSR NKVD. It is believed that the all-USSR secret constabulary increased the figures ab initio introduced by the Ukrainian NKVD. The Table 1 presents the bounds by oblasti ( parts ) of those to be repressed in the Ukraine harmonizing to the order a„-00447.[ 13 ]

Table 1. ‘Limits ‘ in the Ukrayina

Oblast ‘

First class[ 14 ]

Second class[ 15 ]

Entire

Khar’kov

1500

4000

5500

Kiev

2000

3500

5500

Vinnitsa

1000

3000

4000

Stalino

1000

3000

4000

Odesa

1000

3500

4500

Dnepropetrovsk

1000

2000

3000

Chernigov

300

1300

1600

Moldavia ASSR

200

500

700

Entire

8000

20800

28800

It is in vain to seek any logics in the Numberss given by the NKVD. Even if concede that initial figures collected locally had at least some foundation ( former felons, kulaks, former members of different political parties ) , the ulterior hunt for enemies was absurd and nil more than a sort of “ socialist competition ” in apprehensions and executings among the NKVD officers.

3.2. The Ukrainian NKVD

The important trait of the staffing policy at the Ukrainian NKVD during the times of the Great Terror was the lasting rotary motion of head employees. At that clip five individuals were appointed as Narkoms of Internal Affairs 1 after another. The Table 2 represents the rotary motion of cells within the Ukrainian NKVD and emphasizes short term service of the caputs.

Table 2. Heads Rotation within the Ukrainian NKVD[ 16 ]

Head of the Ukrainian NKVD

Appointed

Dismissed

Subsequent stairss

V.A. Balitskyi ( State Security commissioner 1st category )

July 10, 1934

May 17, 1937

sodiums

V.T. Ivanov ( State Security commissioner 3rd category )

May 17, 1937

June 15, 1937

sodiums

I.M. Leplevskyi ( State Security commissioner 2nd category )

June 15, 1937

January 27, 1938

Arrested and shot in July 28, 1938[ 17 ]

O.I. Uspenskyi ( State Security commissioner 3rd category )

January 27, 1938

November 14, 1938

Staged his ain self-destruction, hid for 18 months ; was arrested and shot in January, 1940[ 18 ]

V.V. Osokin ( Division commanding officer )

November 14, 1938

December 14, 1938

sodiums

The individual who introduced a new and stronger moving ridge of the mass repressions in the Ukraine was Israel Leplevskiy, appointed as the caput of the Ukrainian NKVD on June 14/15[ 19 ], 1937. It seemed Leplevskiy was excited about his work: he addressed Yezhov three times inquiring to increase the bounds on both classs. First, the caput of the Ukrainian secret constabulary asked to spread out the bounds for executings on 4A 200 instances, which was granted by Ezhov. Second, already in the terminal of September Leplevskyi requested for addition of the bounds on 4 500 in the first class and 15A 200 in the 2nd class. However, the USSR NKVD granted 3A 000 for the first class and 5A 100 for the 2nd. However, it was non sufficient for Leplevskyi and eventually he asked to add 4A 000 for the first class and 10A 000 for the 2nd. This petition was satisfied by Ezhov in overall dimension.[ 20 ]However, even the high rates of the repressed initiated by Leplevskyi did non fulfill the Soviet NKVD and accordingly he was dismissed and later on shooting.[ 21 ]

Alexander Uspenskyi became the new caput of the Ukrainian NKVD. During his leading another 6A 000 people were repressed and later in February 1938, 30A 000 Ukrainians had their instances completed.[ 22 ]Finally, on November 17, 1938 the mass operations were over and the whole incrimination for repressions was put on the NKVD variety meats who “ behavior [ erectile dysfunction ] mass operations, which simplified the fact-finding procedure and granted ‘limits ‘ for mass apprehensions ”[ 23 ].[ 24 ]Alexander Uspenskyi even faked his ain self-destruction and hid during more than a twelvemonth. However, he was eventually caught and executed.[ 25 ]

Fearing of being dismissed, each caput of the secret constabulary considered increasing of bounds his responsibility. Consequently, the sum of people to be repressed rose on 46A 150[ 26 ]comparison to the bounds established in the order a„- 00447.

3.3. Social Composition of Peoples Repressed in the Ukraine.

One of the chief indexs of political repressions in the period of 1937-1938 was a societal belonging of the arrested. There were several societal groups who faced repressions.[ 27 ]The Table 3 presents the societal construction and sum of the arrested during 1937 in the Ukraine. All the groups were generalized within three classs indicated in the NKVD order No 00447: former kulaks, felons and other anti-Soviet elements.

Table 3. Social Structure of Arrested by the Ukrainian NKVD during 1937[ 28 ]

Groups of repressed

Arrested

( measure of people )

Percentage from the entire sum of the arrested in the Ukrayina

Former “ kulaks ”

66 401

41,6 %

“ Former people ”[ 29 ]

58 502

36,7 %

Declassed elements

14 504

9,1 %

Curates of faith

4 744

3,0 %

Office employees

4 300

2,7 %

Maidservants, dependants, pensionaries

3 035

1,9 %

Individual provincials

2 473

1,5 %

Handicraftsmen

1 389

0,9 %

Members of corporate farms

1 266

0,8 %

Commanding staff of

the Red Army

1 083

0,7 %

Workers

777

0,5 %

Red Army soldiers and junior dominating staff RSChA

864

0,5 %

NKVD employees

236

0,1 %

Entire

159 574

100 %

It is of import to advert that four upper groups consisted 91,4 % of all arrested in the Ukraine during 1937. Nikolskyi points at the fact that the group of “ former people ” was non indicated either in the determination of Politburo of July 2, 1937 or in the order No 00447. Allegedly, these people were to be repressed automatically.[ 30 ]

The Ukrainian party leading besides underwent big graduated table repressions. 55 out of 62 members of the CC CP ( B ) U, elected in June, 1937, were accused of hostile activities. Ten out of 11 members of the Politburo of the CC CP ( B ) U and four out of five campaigners to the Politburo were repressed. All nine members of the Orgburo of Central Committee CP ( B ) U were killed. The first secretary of the CC CP ( B ) U, Stanislav Kosior who had been keeping the station since January 23, 1934, was accused in being a member of POV and was executed in February, 1939. Nikita Khrushchev took the topographic point of the first secretary and held this place till March 3, 1947 sometime later being appointed the First Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.

3.4. National Operations in the Ukrayina

Along with the repressions of cultural Ukrainians, a similar series of steps was launched against Polish, German and other cultural minorities who lived in the Ukraine at that clip. On July 25, 1937 Yezhov signed Order a„-00439, which directed to collar all German citizens including political immigrants and bring out the agents of foreign intelligence. On August 11, 1937 Yezhov issued Order a„-00485 that launched Polish operation – to neutralize local organisation of Polish Military Organization ( POV ) . Due to the fact, that Ukraine had boundary line with Poland and legion German and Polish communities historically, immense Numberss of people were arrested harmonizing to the national operation.[ 31 ]

In contrast to “ kulak ” operation, bounds for the national operations were non established.[ 32 ]However, Nikolskyi states that political repressions directed on Poles, Germans and Greeks were much more terrible than against other nationalities. Furthermore, he argues that the measure of people repressed along the national lines normally exceeded the sum of representatives of these minorities in the society. It is appropriate to advert here the sum of arrested among cultural minorities and the correlativity to the entire sum of the population during 1937 ( see Table 4 ) .[ 33 ]

Table 4. Repressions against Cultural Minorities in the Ukraine during 1937

Nationality

Arrested

Percentage from the entire population

Percentage from the sum of pent-up

Ukrainians

84 915

78,2

53,2

Poles

30 148

1,5

18,9

Germans

16 228

1,4

10,2

Russians

12 291

11,3

7,7

Hebrews

4 097

5,2

2,6

Hellenics

3 689

0,4

2,3

Belorussians

1 292

0,4

0,8

Others

6 972

1,6

1, 3

Entire

159 632

100

100

In hunt for foreign undercover agents the Ukrainian NKVD arrested everyone who had any relation to cultural minorities – Polish or German family name, engagement in trips abroad or relations who lived out of the Soviet Union, and foreigners from Galicia.[ 34 ]The Ukrainian scientist Nikolskyi points to the facts discovered in the declassified Soviet archives which prove the random pick of the Polish “ unsafe elements ” .[ 35 ]Indeed, due to the deficiency of card index, the NKVD officers searched for any family name that could resemble the Polish one in telephone books.[ 36 ]

After the assignment of Uspenskyi as a caput of the Ukrainian NKVD, Yezhov issued directing to increase the sum of pent-up persons. The “ operation for the routing of espionage-wrecking contingents of Poles, Letts, Germans, Estonians, Finns, Greeks, Iranians, Kharbins, Chinese, Romanians of both foreign and Soviet citizenship, in conformity with matching USSR NKVD orders ”[ 37 ]was to be continued until April 15, 1938.[ 38 ]

The political orientation of the national operations can be identified even from the direction given by Uspenskiy to the freshly appointed caput of Vinnitsa oblast ‘ NKVD Korablev. He said: “ ‘all Germans and Poles populating in the Ukraine are undercover agents and wreckers ‘ and ’75-80 per cent of Ukrainians are bourgeois patriots ‘ ”[ 39 ]

3.5. Specific Character of the Great Terror in the Ukrayina

Harmonizing to the Ukrainian historian Stanislav Kulchytsky, during 1937-1938, 265 699 people were arrested in the Ukraine, and “ 198 918 instances were committed for test. 62 % ( 123 329 people ) were shot [ aˆ¦ ] , 34,7 % ( 68 823 ) sent to labour cantonments, 2,1 % ( 4 124 ) imprisoned, 0,5 % ( 1 067 ) exiled, and 0,3 % ( 658 ) released ”[ 40 ]. Appendix 3 nowadayss the diagram with quantitative proportion of the repressed in the Ukraine.

If the per centum of repressed cultural minorities can explained by the propinquity to Polish and Rumanian boundary lines, traditional multi-ethnicity of Ukrainian population ; per centum of ‘kulaks ‘ may be explained by the fact that Ukraine had huge bulk of rural population most of which were easy identified as ‘kulaks ‘ by the NKVD ; the 3rd class – members of businessperson, nationalist organisations – had deeper political roots.

After the triumph of the October revolution in the Ukraine, there was a immense rise of the national-liberation motion, inspired so by Lenin ‘s thesis on right for self-identification of states. Despite the fact that attempts to make a Ukrainian national province – Ukrainian National Republic – failed in 1917-1921, the rebuilding of national individuality after the old ages of Tsarist regulation continued with creative activity of the USSR. From 1923 till the terminal of 1920-s the ‘Ukrainization ‘ policy was officially implemented by the Soviet leading. Huge reforms in instruction, administration and civilization were designed to convey Ukrainian linguistic communication in instruction, Ukrainians to the regulating organic structures, develop Ukrainian theater and film. A figure of Ukrainian political parties existed – Borotbisty ( Ukrainian Left Social Revolutionaries ) , UKP ( Ukrainian left socialists ) and others.

The policy of ‘Ukrainization ‘ was cancelled together with NEP, and everyone who implemented it as a province policy uniting societal release with national in 1920-s, were labeled ‘bourgeois patriots ‘ and repressed in 1930-s. This is why in the times of the Great Terror about every Ukrainian could be blamed as patriot, and officers of the NKVD fabricated 1000s of instances all over Ukraine against ‘nationalist resistance ‘ .

3.6. Exoneration of Victims

At the bend of 1989-90-s and in the ulterior old ages one of the chief authorities and NGOs ‘ activity was exposing the truth about political repressions and print the overall figure of the pent-up citizens. First necessary stairss were made by the former USSR in 1988 when local direction of KGB and Republican commissions were received the edict to reexamine the KGB condemnable instances and to acquit guiltless victims of the Great Terror.

A important drift to the activization of the exoneration procedure and betterment in methods of work was the acceptance of Law “ On Rehabilitation of Victims of Political Repression in the Ukraine ” in April 17, 1991. Interestingly plenty, the Ukraine adopted the mentioned statute law the first among other former Soviet democracies.[ 41 ]

Harmonizing to the SBU informations in 1997, they had reviewed 259A 927 archival condemnable instances and decided 212A 052 citizens to be exonerated and 84A 717 citizens to decline an exoneration. It was explained by the handiness of cogent evidence of guilt in the condemnable instances of such citizens. Those people who attempted or really deserted were considered as non holding a possibility to be rehabilitated.[ 42 ]However, this issue is rather controversial. Harmonizing to research workers who examined the instances, barely any instance consists of any cogent evidence despite the scrutiny record with self-condemnation[ 43 ], which was made by the individual after well-known anguishs. Thereby, it is non clear how the SBU distinguished who was so involved in anti-Soviet offense and who was non.

4. The Burial Grounds of the Great Panic

Stalinist leading tried to conceal all the information about the conducted repressions and to maintain a secret of the topographic points of mass entombment of victims. However, it is obvious that the slaughter of such a great figure of people could non be hidden. After WWII many topographic points of mass entombments have been exposed, however, about until the prostration of the Soviet Union the official propaganda has been saying that there were buried victims of the Nazi business.

Since 1991 some of the archives of the NKVD have become available, giving the possibility to retrace the image and to acquit the victims of the Great Terror. The authorities has supported the building of the memorial composites marking the victims who were sentenced to be shot or who died because of the rough conditions in the labour cantonments. There are about 18 such topographic points throughout the Ukraine.

Yet in the terminal of February 1989 the caput of KGB Ukrainian SSR M. Golushko sent a secret missive to the first secretary of CC of Ukrainian Communist Party V. Sherbitskyi. The missive contained a list of topographic points of mass entombments of pent-up people during 1937-1938. They are presented in the Appendix 4. The biggest mass burial evidences were in Vinnitsa and in the wood near the small town Bykivnya which is close to Kyiv.[ 44 ]

Vasil Danilenko, employee of the Sectoral province archive of SBU and a professor, reported that during the Great Terror the topographic points of mass entombments were exhaustively concealed. There were controlled-access installations of KGB, edifice evidences where people were buried at the deepness of 2,5 metres. Very frequently cadaver were concreted or the country was leveled off and so planted with trees. Furthermore, sometimes people who lived in the vicinity were told that it was a mass burial topographic point of the dead people from typhus or any other infective diseases. Consequently, local people were kept in a fright of being infected and tried non to near to the district.[ 45 ]

However, there were many people who happened to be informants of the NKVD activities. Thankss to informants and declassified NKVD archives, one can retrace the “ monotony ” of the Great Terror times in the Ukraine. Following subchapter will research the history of Bykivnia Graves National History Memorial Preserve which was one of the topographic points of mass entombments during 1937-1938.

4.1. Bykivnya: Victims of the Great Terror or the Nazi Occupation?

One of the biggest mass burial evidences in the Ukraine is situated in wood near the aforesaid small town Bykivnia. Harmonizing to SBU stuffs in 1936 there was created a installation of particular intent[ 46 ], which was purely guarded by the NKVD. On March 20, 1937 during the dark, the metropolis council made a secret order for utilizing the land as a burial topographic point for the people executed by hiting during 1937-38 in Kiev by the determination of the tribunals and judicial organic structures. The sentences were executed in the cellar of the Kiev office of the regional disposal of the NKVD ( now there is the Ukrainian Institute of National Remembrance, Lipska str. 16 ) , Bodies were taken to Bykivnia by dark. Sometimes people were changeable right in forepart of the dug holes.[ 47 ]One of the informants recalled that he heard the studies of shootings coming from the Bykivnya ‘s forest.[ 48 ]In contrast, the other informant was certain that shootings ne’er rang out, although he noticed trucks repeatedly traveling to and from that topographic point.[ 49 ]However, the same individual did non hear the noise of building of the installation, although it would do much noise caused by constructing equipment.

Excavations were made by the governmental committee three times[ 50 ]in 1971, 1987 and 1989. After the apprehension of three adolescents in the mid of 1971 who were looting the entombments with the remainders of human skeletons near the small town Bykivnya, the KGB officers were sent to analyze the topographic point. Harmonizing to their study they concluded several things:

events associated with the executing of people found buried in the cavities, refer to the period of the Great Patriotic War ;

killed people before the decease were non in a gaol, most likely, they were concentrated in the cantonment ;

the figure of the shooting and buried in the cavities is likely about two 1000 people ;

most of the killed people seem to be urban inhabitants.[ 51 ]

Following this, the governmental committee had revealed the topographic point of entombments and concluded:

There were discovered the remains of the Soviet Army officers ‘ bags, an star for a chapeau and buttons from the Soviet Army soldiers ‘ uniform. In add-on, we found a important figure of objects and the remains of the apparels comparable with civilian form, including chapeaus, gum elastic overshoes, porcelain cups, enamel mugs, spectacless, combs, razors, prosthetic pess, and objects of the female lavatory.

In a figure of cavities we found slugs and cartridge instances from the rifle and handgun of foreign pattern [ aˆ¦ ] The committee concluded that cadavers are the remainders of citizens shot by Hitlerites during the business of Kyiv in 1941-1943.[ 52 ]

It is non surprising that the governmental committee had found different things associated with WWII, because it could so happened that during the business of Kyiv the Nazis killed Ukrainians in Bykivnya. One individual from the small town has told that during the business Germans had ordered rural inhabitants to come and see at that topographic point in order to cognize the workss of communism.[ 53 ]However, surprising is that the committee did non happen any grounds of the intent of the “ installation behind the green fencing ” such as personal things of repressed. Have non found or did non desire to officially declare discoveries? Was it a use of public attending or deficiency of grounds? However, even if to presume that they concealed the truth and the committee found victims of the Terror, why did people take mugs and cups with them for the executing? It is the inquiry to be answered in the hereafter research, although personally I incline to the sentiment that the burial land contains both changeable “ Anti-Soviet elementsA» and WWII victims, as it was supposed in the paragraph.

In 1987 the governmental committee decided that it was a burial land of WWII victims every bit good. However they found:

aˆ¦ many cups, including a important figure of white earthenware cups with letterings in Polish “ Olevsk ” . There were detected horn-rimmed spectacless, spoons, keys, toothbrushes of German production, fictile combs, including of the Austrian production [ … ] Age of the inhumed persons was from 18 to seventy old ages, the chief portion – 25-45 old ages. Among the remains largely work forces ‘s skulls were found.[ 54 ]

Very interesting here is the mentioned “ Polish ” word “ Olevsk ” . The thing is that there is no such word in Polish, but there is a little metropolis in Zhytomirska oblast where the Olevskyy electrical porcelain mill is with more than hundred old ages ‘ history. Due to the fact that the elaborate history of the mill is non available, and since the production of faience and porcelain is rather similar, but differs in proportions of the ingredients, this mill could bring forth porcelain in the first half of the 20th century. Furthermore, harmonizing to the testimony of one of the predators, all the cups they had found contained hallmarks of the Soviet production.[ 55 ]All of this prompted to the idea that the officer who saw the cup could seek to dissemble the Ukrainian word under the Polish 1 with effort to obscure the truth and to give an baleful[ 56 ]touch to the instance. Consequently, it allows us to see the whole study incorporating delusory elements and, therefore, being non dependable.

The last digging, which for the first clip illuminated the Bykivnya instance, were held in 1989 and the drift to it was a phone call in January 29, 1989 to the prosecuting officer ‘s office in Kyiv from a certain Klimov, who informed that in 1985 in the wood near the small town Bykivnya he had found a cigar holder with the lettering “ V.A. Bryl 16.09.1937 ” . This cigar holder helped the research workers to happen a condemnable instance and to happen out victim ‘s fate.[ 57 ]At that clip many informants ‘ testimonies, of those who marauded or passed by the topographic point, were exposed. Many of them contained the information refering the foreign money ( normally Czech and Polish ) and foreign footwear ( chiefly of German production ) found at the Bykivnya wood. Some of the “ adventurers ” has found a note of the undermentioned contents: “ We are at the NKVD, we are being tortured [ aˆ¦ ] for no ground ”[ 58 ].

On different histories, the figure of victims buried in Bykivnia varies from 10 thousand to several tonss of 1000s. However, returning to the issue of the beginning of victims, it makes sense for the SBU to stipulate at least about the measure of victims of the Great Terror and of WWII who were buried in the cavities behind the green fencing.

All stated above purpose to indicate at the fact that testimonies of informants can non be the lone beginning of exposing the truth, but instead function an drift to the undermentioned research. The lone process which might be capable of clarifying is prescription of decease coming with the aid of information engineering, which is rather expensive in the Ukraine and can non be used on history of other province precedences.

4.2. Social and National Structure of Repressed in the Kyivska oblast

Since Bykivnya is considered to embrace chiefly victims from Kyivska oblast, it makes sense to bespeak the societal and national construction of the repressed. Unfortunately, empirical information is available merely for 1937, nevertheless, the inclination of the 1938 may be assumed. Table 5 nowadayss the national classs of the repressed. It is noteworthy from the tabular array that Kyivska oblast was one of the leaders in the repressions race, particularly in the executing of Ukrainians.

Table 5. National Structure of Repressed in the 1937[ 59 ]

National individuality

Number of the pent-up

Percentage from the entire sum of the repressed in this class in the Ukrayina

Ratio among other oblasti

Ukrainians

15A 409

18,2

1

Russians

939

7,6

5

Poles

3 058

10

5

Germans

629

3,9

6

Hebrews

692

16,8

2

Table 6. Social Structure of Arrested in the 1937[ 60 ]

Social individuality

Number of the arrested

Percentage of the arrested from the entire sum of arrested of this class in the Ukrayina

Percentage from the entire sum of arrested in the Ukrayina

Ratio among other oblasti

Former “ kulaks ”

7 374

11,1

34,5

3

“ Former people ”[ 61 ]

9 892

16,9

46,3

3

Declassed elements

2 239

15,4

10,5

3

Curates of faith

941

19,8

4,4

3

Office employees

114

2,7

0,5

3

Maidservants, dependants, pensionaries

348

11,5

1,6

3

Individual provincials

65

2,6

0,3

3

Handicraftsmen

16

1,2

0,1

3

Members of corporate farms

33

2,6

0,2

3

Commanding staff of

the Red Army

119

11,0

0,6

3

Workers

49

6,3

0,2

3

Red Army soldiers and junior dominating staff RSChA

166

19,2

0,7

3

NKVD employees

18

7,6

0,1

3

Entire

21 374

100

Table 6 nowadayss societal construction of the arrested in the Ukraine during 1937. It shows that Kyivska oblast was once more one of the leaders in the race for executings of different societal classs of people every bit good as in repression of cultural minorities. However, it was non on a top place, which was held by Donetska oblast.

5. Decision

Physical devastation of citizens in the Ukrainian SSR began instantly after the October putsch in 1917. Although repressions aimed to impact certain classs of people such as party members, military work forces, clerisy, workers and provincials, they did impact every individual straight or indirectly. Unprecedented graduated table of mass repression came after unreal dearth of 1932 – 1933.

The net consequence of the mass repressions was physical extinction of active and intelligent portion of the state and moral depraving of those who were non touched by the panic. Stalinist panic likely was one of the cruelest devastation of the population in ain state. It is no happenstance that Robert Conquest called the period of repressions as the Great Terror.

To sum up, the barbarous slaughter of those who were considered oppositions of the Soviet regulation in the Ukraine began yet in 1920-s. However, merely in 1930-s the Ukrainian people faced the existent calamity of “ Holodomor ” and “ The Great Terror ” . The extremum of repressions during the old ages of the Great Terror in the Ukraine was the 2nd half of 1937. A crisp diminution in repression occurred in the 2nd half of 1938. It is estimated that during the period of the Great Terror 265 thousand 699 people were arrested. 123 thousand 329 people were convicted to the alleged “ high grade of societal protection ” ( executing ) . During the 1937-1938 the classs of people who suffered particularly greatly were husbandmans, intellectuals, functionaries, and a spot less than other workers. At the same clip military repressions, peculiarly against the Red Army, junior and senior staff of the Red Army, boundary line military personnels, and employees of the NKVD intensified.

The policy of ‘Ukrainization ‘ , which was cancelled some clip after its execution, and the geopolitical location played a important function in the intensive character of the panic in the Ukraine. One of the most populated oblasti in the Ukraine, viz. Kyivska, hold about top place in the “ war with anti-Soviet elements ” . Despite the fact of the credence by the Ukrainian leading and public the calamity of Bykivnya, there are still many controversial issues to be researched.

Bibliography

Amens, A.I. Bykibnyanska tragediya. Kyiv: Ukrainskyi tsentr duhovnoi kulturi, 2006.

Bilokin ‘ , S.I. Massoviy panic kak sredstvo gosudarstvennogo upravleniya V SSSR ( 1917-1941 ) . Kyiv: NAN Ukraini, 2000.

Burdenyuk, Volodimir. “ Doroga omega pekla. ” Z archiviv VUChK GPU NKVD KGB. Naukovyi one dokumentalnyi jurnal, 1995: 166-176.

Danilenko V.M. , Kas’yanov G.V. , Kul’chickiy S.V. Stalinizm na Ukraini: 20-30-ti roki. Kiev: Lubid ‘ , 1991.

“ Delo a„- 13. Podlinniki dokladnih zapisok, specialnih I informacionnih soobshenii / vozvrat iz CK Kompartii Ukraini/ . ” O poiske mest zahoronenii jertv repressii V godi narushenii socialisticheskoi zakonnosti. February 28, 1989.

Kulchytsky, Stanislav. “ STALIN ‘S GIFT TO THE SOVIET ELECTORATE. ” The Day Weekly Digest, April 17 a„-12, 2007: hypertext transfer protocol: //action-ukraine-report.blogspot.com/2007/04/aur832-apr-22-stalins-great-terror-70.html.

Liber, George. Soviet nationality policy, urban growing, and individuality alteration in the Ukrainian SSR, 1923-1934. Cambridge University Press, 1992.

Lyabah, O.D. “ Nas zapituyut. ” Z arhiviv VUChK GPU NKVD KGB: Naukovyi i dokumentalnyi jurnal, 1997: 437-439.

Nikolskyi, V.M. “ Nacionalni aspekti politichnih represiy 1937 r. V Ukraini. ” Ukrainskyi istorichnyi jurnal, a„-2 2001: 74-89.

– . “ Represii za “ limitami ” ( 1937-1938 rr. ) . ” Ukrainskyi istorichnyi jurnal, a„-3 2006: 210-223.

– . “ Sotsialnyi sklad represovanih V Ukraini U 1937 r. ” Ukrainskyi istorichnyi jurnal, a„-1 2001: 141-162.

Subtelny, Orest. Ukrayina: a history. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2000.

UNIAN-Den ‘ . “ SBU vstanovila 18 misc ‘ pohovan ‘ strachenih V NKVD. ” April 15, 2009: 41-43.

V. Pristaiko, O.Pshennikov, Y.Shapoval. “ Litopis “ Velikogo teroru ” : Shlyah na solovki. ” Z arhiviv VUChK GPU NKVD KGB: Naukovyi i dokumentalnyi jurnal, 1998: 105-134.

Vasiliev, Valerii. “ The Great Terror in the Ukraine, 1936-1938. ” In Stalin ‘s Terror Revisited, by edited by Melanie Ilic, 140-162. Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006.

Werth, Nicolas. “ The Great Terror ( 1936-1938 ) . ” In The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression, by Stephane Courtois, Nocolas Werth, Jean-Louis Panne, Andrzej Paczkowski, Karel Bartosek and Jean-Louis Margolin, 184-202. London: Harvard University Press, 1999.

Zolotarev, Vadim. “ Kerivnyi sklad NKVS URSR pelvic inflammatory disease chas “ velikogo teroru ” ( 1936-1938 rr. ) : sotsialno-statistichniy analiz. ” Z arhiviv VUChK GPU NKVD KGB, a„-2 2009: 86-115.

Appendix 1

Ukrainians as a per centum of full rural population of the Ukrainian SSR, 1926[ 62 ]

Appendix 2

Repressions in CP ( B ) Uracil

Appendix 3

Victims of the Great Terror during 1937-1938 in the Ukrayina[ 63 ]